Ryan Murphy’s Controversial 9-Part Drama Is Officially Taking Over America
Ryan Murphy’s Controversial 9-Part Drama Is Officially Taking Over America
Greer RiddellSat, May 9, 2026 at 8:48 PM UTC
0
Image via FX
The 1990s are still in vogue this spring, with Love Story: JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette, Ryan Murphy’s controversial nine-part FX drama, experiencing a second life on streaming. Months after its February debut, the series is finding a fresh audience on the Apple TV Store, with viewers drawn in by its mix of romance, tragedy, and nostalgia.
The first installment of Murphy’s American Love Storyanthology series revisits one of the most scrutinized relationships of the late twentieth century in John F. Kennedy Jr., the son of President John F. Kennedy and Jacqueline Kennedy Onassis, and Carolyn Bessette, a Calvin Klein publicist who became a style icon in her own right. Their relationship played out under constant media attention, turning them into the defining “it” couple of the 1990s. After its premiere, Love Story went on to become FX’s most-watched limited series on Hulu and Disney+, with its hashtag generating over 21 million posts globally.
Paul Anthony Kelly and Sarah Pidgeon Lead FX's ‘Love Story’
Image via Eric Liebowitz/FX
Love Story's popularity is indebted to its performances. Paul Anthony Kelly takes on the impossible task of embodying the most eligible bachelor in America, while Sarah Pidgeon tackles the relatively private Bessette. Both could easily feel like impressions, yet the actors' anonymity works in the show’s favor. Pidgeon’s portrayal captures Carolyn's increasing fragility, while Kelly presents John as charismatic yet burdened by expectation.
The series also leans heavily into fashion via access to Carolyn's world at Calvin Klein. The same mythic quality attached to Klein (Alessandro Nivola) and the fashion industry also extends to John and Carolyn themselves. These are elite, high-profile circles that most people never see, but Love Story places viewers firmly inside those rooms, asking them to believe this version of the Kennedy orbit. Another notable performance is from Grace Gummer, who stars as the composed Caroline Kennedy. She is a tragic figure in her own right, trying desperately to maintain the family’s public image in the absence of her mother while carrying the weight of its recurring tragedies.
Advertisement
“Battery Park” Is 'Love Story’s Most Memorable Episode
JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette facing each other in a park
Episode 5, “Battery Park,” stands out as a defining moment in Love Story. John brings Carolyn to Hyannis Port to meet his extended family at the Kennedy compound. The episodeinvites comparisons to Netflix’s The Crown, offering an outsider the chance to get up close and personal with this dynasty, where insiders are watching to see whether they sink or swim. Ethel Kennedy’s (Jessica Harper) cool reception sets the tone, and Carolyn’s discomfort grows as she navigates expectations she never signed up for. John proposes privately, but Carolyn hesitates, unsure how their lives fit together. When news of the proposal leaks, it overshadows John’s professional ambitions and sparks a public denial that hurts Carolyn deeply.
Their eventual argument in Battery Park becomes a turning point — messy, public, and linked to real images of the couple. By the end, and after a quieter, more honest conversation, Carolyn agrees to marry John; however, Episode 6, "The Wedding," brings more warning than romance. The pressures of marrying into the Kennedy family become impossible to ignore when Carolyn’s mother, Ann (Constance Zimmer), voices concerns about the life ahead, noting both relentless press attention and John’s inevitable political future.
The tone darkens again in the second half of the series as the couple returns to New York. After facing constant intrusion from the media, Carolyn’s mental health begins to decline significantly. In Episode 8, “Exit Strategy,” Carolyn watches coverage of Princess Diana's fatal car crash — uncomfortable viewing that foreshadows Love Story’s own ending. The aftermath of the tragic flight depicted in the show's finale focuses on those left behind, predominantly Caroline Kennedy and Edwin Schlossberg (Ben Shenkman), as well as a tense fictional confrontation between Ann and the Kennedy family. It reinforces the series' central idea that while John and Carolyn's love story felt magical in the moment, it carried warning signs that only others could clearly see.
Love Story: JFK Jr. and Carolyn Bessette's trending position on the Apple TV Store is hardly a surprise. The romance remains the entry point, but what keeps people watching is the access it offers into the Kennedy family life, fashion, and fame at a level usually out of reach.
Source: “AOL Entertainment”
